What if the First Oath Meant You Couldn’t Lie to Yourself?
This post is supposed to be about the eleventh chapter of
New Spring, but in re-reading it, I learned something important. Nothing in
this chapter is remotely interesting.
It’s the chapter in which Siuan and Moiraine are raised to
the shawl. There’s a ceremony, they take the oaths, and other than fan service,
I suspect the narrative purpose of the chapter is to emphasize just how close
Moiraine and Siuan are. Fine, whatever.
I found the chapter title interesting. It’s “Just Before
Dawn” and is a reference to the time at which they leave for the ceremony. It
only interests me in juxtaposition to the idea of He Who Comes At Dawn. Here we
have a quest-goer-onner who achieves validation by going to something before
dawn. Later we’ll have a quest-fulfiller who achieves validation by returning
from something at dawn. I don’t know if that was deliberate—I suspect it was—but
it was slightly interesting.
So WTF am I going to do with this post? I’m going to go off
on a tangent and wonder what might have been if things had been different. As
soon as Moiraine takes the first oath—the one that prohibits lying—she thinks a
What if she couldn’t? What if the First Oath made it
impossible to lie to yourself? What if, in any question where there is an
objectively true answer, that you could not think something that contradicted
It’s Supposed to be Good, but The White Tower
is Divisive as Hell
The Shadow wishes it could divide the forces of the Light
the way the White Tower has. It drives wedges between almost literally
Okay First…the Test Isn’t Lame
I said in the post on the previous chapter that the test
seemed lame, especially compared to Elaida’s torture. It seems I forgot some
details and that the test got a lot worse physically as Moiraine left the test
exhausted and with several injuries.
The Divisions of the White Tower
The White Tower drives everyone apart.
In Moiraine’s last test, she is forced to leave her family
in dire circumstances. When Egwene and Nynaeve go through the test to become
Accepted, they are also forced to repeatedly abandon those they care about the
most to become Aes Sedai.
There’s some sense to this. As channelers, Aes Sedai are
going to live much longer than their non-channeling families, so they have to
get used to the loss. In addition, by living so long, they’re forced to think
of the long-term because they will live to see the consequences of their
Only Madmen Entered the Blight Willingly
This chapter feels almost entirely like fan service. It
depicts the start of Moiraine’s trip through the testing ter’angreal but
doesn’t reveal much—if anything—about her nature that we didn’t already know.
The last chapter ended with her getting the call, so this
one begins as she’s escorted to the testing. She’s afraid she’s going to fail
but realizes that if she fails, she still has her book of names and the
resources of the scion of House Damodred. She resolves that she’ll begin the
quest for the Dragon Reborn in a few days regardless and this alieves her
anxiety about the test. (more…)
The Hard is what Makes it Good
This chapter has always been a strange one for me in that
the only thing that happens—Elaida tortures Moiraine and Siuan in the guise of
practicing for the test—and it seems disconnected from everything else that
happens in the story.
From a story structure perspective, it ramps up the stakes
right before Moiraine is called for the test. This is so clearly the entire
point of the chapter that everything from the Foretelling to this incident
happened within seven days. Two more days pass before they see Elaida again,
then on the tenth day the weather breaks and the snow melts. Moiraine is called
nine days after the thaw. Everything from the thaw to the time Moiraine is
called happens in one paragraph.
The big question about this incident is always whether
Elaida is trying to help them succeed at the test or whether she’s trying to
get them to fail. I’ll talk about that in a moment, but first I want to address
some of the details that bookend the incident. (more…)
Thrones, Schmones, This Game is for Whole Houses
On a casual read, this feels like one of those chapters that
are relatively meaningless. It’s the one where Siuan and Moiraine are sent with
letters to assorted Aes Sedai from which Moiraine concludes that the Reds aren’t
to be trusted and that the Amyrlin intends to keep the whole matter a secret.
This is, of course, important because that’s precisely what
Siuan and Moiraine do.
If you read just a wee bit deeper, though, this chapter is about
two things: breaking the rules and showing Moiraine’s strengths. (more…)
Siuan Looks Ahead. Moiraine Looks to Run
I confess that in previous re-reads of New Spring, I’ve
often skipped this chapter. For those of you who don’t know the contents of
every chapter in the entire series off the top of your head, a) shame on you,
and b) it’s the one where Siuan and Moiraine start copying over names of the
women who gave birth.
The previous chapter ended with Merean informing Moiraine
that her uncles—King Laman and his brothers—had been killed by the Aiel. This
chapter begins with Merean telling Moiraine that she’s spoken with the Amyrlin
and they agree that because Moiraine isn’t in a horrific depression, she must
be in shock and thus should stay home from the name gathering.
There are a couple interesting things here.
Moiraine isn’t all that broken up over her uncles because
she knows they were terrible people who weren’t kind to her father. The Aes
Sedai—who are as famously un-emotional as Jedi—think her lack of emotion is
reflective of shock instead of a perfectly natural reaction to some bad people
That’s weird. (more…)
The Wheel Weaves the Future out of the Past
While the first four chapters of New Spring follow a
predictable formula, the fifth and sixth chapters are dedicated to giving us a
further understanding of our two protagonists by showing us their strengths and
These strengths and weakness stem primarily from the way
they were raised. Siuan was raised as a woman on a working-class fishing vessel
where the work came first, and politeness and decorum were a secondary or
tertiary consideration if they were considered at all. If she wanted something
done, she had to take charge and make sure it got done.
Moiraine on the other hand, grew up in a palace with a long
list of people there to help her get whatever she wanted and a very short list
of people who could tell her what to do. (more…)
All the Greatest Adventures Begin with Paperwork, Right?
When I first decided to do this re-read project, I asked
Twitter whether I should start with New Spring or The Eye of The World and Twitter
overwhelmingly recommended TEOTW so obviously I did the opposite.
It wasn’t just my congenital inability to do as I’m told. I
generally start re-reads with New Spring, and I thought I would take a look at
them both to see what might make for a good beginning.
I didn’t get past the Table of Contents.
I’m a bit of a story nerd, and I’ve read more books on story
structure than is healthy. There’s a part of every story where the hero is in
their ordinary world before they get called to action and everything goes to
That part of the story is often called The Hook and there,
sitting in the Table of Contents was a first chapter titled “The Hook.”
The wheel weaves as it will and all that.
The first parts of most stories have the same structure. The
hero is in their normal world. Something happens that changes everything. The
hero is called to action. They leave their normal world for a world of
adventure where they face new dangers.
That’s the first four chapters of New Spring. (more…)
Breaking the Rules to Do the Right Thing
The third chapter of New Spring deals with Siuan and
Moiraine in the immediate aftermath of hearing the foretelling about the Dragon
Reborn. As such, it deals a lot with their reaction to the news—Siuan is excited
and Moiraine is terrified—as well as their relationship. It sets up a scene
coming up with Elaida and introduces several ancillary characters we see later
in the series.
I’m not talking about any of that. (more…)
In the second chapter of New Spring, we see the rebirth of
the Dragon as Foretold by Gitara Moroso, and while I was initially planning
this post, I was thinking of it as the Inciting Incident for the four-million-plus
words that follow.
But that’s not right.
It’s not the foretelling that’s the inciting incident; it’s
the rebirth of the Dragon itself. That realization made me question why Robert
Jordan would present us the information this way. To be sure, at publication,
we already knew the bare facts, and this chapter was all about introducing
Moiraine Damodred, Siuan Sanche, and the Aes Sedai.
But there’s more. (more…)